There’s been a lot of chatter on the fan Forum ever since The Black Keys mentioned on their Facebook page that there would be “changes in the live show”. Fans have only ever known two guys on stage rockin hard.
Irrespective of how the ‘Keys perform their songs live (announcement to be made very shortly), there are so many possibilities of how things could turn out including their set lists. This all got me thinking about what my fantasy Black Keys gig would be like.
If the ‘Keys could play anything to please you live what would it be? What would your fantasy Black Keys live show consist of?
Every fan hopes they’ll play their favourite songs. Realistically a band can never please everyone, so they’re probably better off trying to get some sort of compromise between keeping themselves happy and most of the audience. Live shows should be different to the album. It was a point emphasised by Tchad Blake, who mixed Brothers, and has seemingly been embraced more and more by the band. Dan’s ‘Keep It Hid’ record was certainly a case in point when played live.
Forgetting a past dream, which is still an ultimate fantasy gig, here’s how I envisage a show panning out. Basically, it centres on a show they never play, or rather songs and elements of their career, looking forward and back – taking some of those elements and pushing the boundaries even further and in so doing highlighting the musicality and lyrical strength of the band. I don’t want to just hear the fuzzed out banging tunes every time – I’ve seen enough of those shows. I’d like to think I’ve moved on as I’ve got older just like the band has.
Maybe some inspired festival booker or promoter could talk the band into this type of show? No doubt it might be a few years off as a one off retrospective/showcase or All Tomorrows Parties-type show.
My fantasy show would be broken into three parts.
It would start with a set of Blakroc instrumentals to ease the crowd in. I’m surprised the band hasn’t experimented with more instrumentals generally. I’d hope Gil Scott Heron might come on for some tracks. Though he didn’t appear on the Blakroc release if you’ve listened to his new album or past ones you’ll get a sense of what could be possible if the Black Keys really opened up. It could be something pushing the boundaries of, what I’d call, blues-beat tracks.
Chulahoma. This would be the second set. If just once the band would play these tracks live. It’s a perfect segue into more rockin but mid-tempo tracks. Straight up play the album through would be sweet as.
The final set would feature the slow soul drenched Brothers tracks. No doubt the concert just like the album would leave everyone wanting more – just how it should be. If anything, after a few listens, I wish Dan and Pat had actually pushed their soul tracks even further. No doubt there were plenty surprised faces at their record label when they first played the new cuts. Backed with further musicians and instrumentation, no doubt the hope despair redemption of the songs will be accentuated.
The Setlist:
First set
Hope You’re Happy
On The Vista
Stay Off The Fuckin Flowers
Aint Nothing Like You (Hoochie Coo)
Hard Times
Dollaz and Sense
Why Can’t I Forget Him
WhaT You Do To Me
Second set
Keep Your Hands Off Her
Have Mercy on Me
Work Me
Meet Me in the City
Nobody But You
My Mind is Ramblin’
Third Set
The Only One
Too Afraid to Love You
Ten Cent Pistol
Sinister Kid
The Go Getter
I’m Not the One
Unknown Brother
These Days
Related posts:
- The Black Keys’ New Live Show 2010
- Dan Auerbach Concert Ticket and Live Show Reviews
- Black Keys Live Show Reviewers Needed
- Video: The Black Keys’ Live On BBC Radio 1 2012
- The Black Keys’ Best Live Versions Of Busted
Want to discuss The Black Keys with other fans? Check out The Black Keys Fan Lounge Forum here



I’m going to see them in Philly July 30th, and I hope they play your third set. And Howlin’ For You as well.
I’m pretty well excited to hear the new tracks tracks to be honest with you. So… I take it that you guys have already heard them? Even though album’s not out yet?
I would love to see a one-time “downers tour” where The Keys play more mellow songs from the catalogue . . . including a lot from Chulahoma.
I love that the band always plays a high octane set list. You know exactly what you’re going to get going into a show . . . well, until you have to SIT with Kings of Leon fans this Fall. The recent surprise show in Birmingham, Alabama was actually pretty spot on:
Thickfreakness > Girl Is On My Mind > Set You Free > 10 AM Automatic > The Breaks > Stack Shot Billy > Busted > Everywhere I Go > Strange Times > Your Touch > Same Old Thing > No Trust > Have Love Will Travel > and of course, I Got Mine
Ah, what a fantastic discussion topic.
I would LOVE to hear “My Mind Is Ramblin’”, “You’re The One”, “I Cry Alone”, “Things Ain’t Like They Used To Be” and “I’ll Be Your Man” in a really intimate setting. I wish I could go to the New York Bookstore show next week, but unfortunately being on the West Coast for now won’t let me get there =[.
@Johnny, you can hear a First Listen here: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=126607501&sc=fb&cc=fp
@Brucini, as always, you have awesome input.