The Black Keys Fan Lounge Forum » Music

mdevans

serious fan
Joined: Jun '10
Posts: 59

offline

mdevans

Had a go at the do the rump studio version, bit sloppy, but let us no what you think!

Get the Video Plugin

Posted 1 month ago #

Danleary

drunken admirer
Joined: Sep '09
Posts: 394

offline

Danleary

You are out of tune and I think it ruined what would have otherwise been amazing. You seem to have the song down really well. A few timing issues but nothing huge. And that guitar looks beautiful.

Posted 1 month ago #

MirbyGnits

roadie
Joined: Apr '10
Posts: 2,174

offline

MirbyGnits

Removed by user?

This system requires equal parts broke-ass shit to equal parts hot-ass shit.
Posted 1 month ago #

mdevans

serious fan
Joined: Jun '10
Posts: 59

offline

mdevans

havin another go at it

Posted 1 month ago #

mdevans

serious fan
Joined: Jun '10
Posts: 59

offline

mdevans

Get the Video Plugin

Second try, still pretty damn sloppy but you get the idea i guess

Posted 1 month ago #

Danleary

drunken admirer
Joined: Sep '09
Posts: 394

offline

Danleary

That was a lot better, good job. Still sounds a bit out of tune but not as bad as it was. Do you have an electronic tuner?

+1 for picking one of the more challenging songs, most people seem to do the easy stuff. Kinda funny... out of all their albums, I've found the stuff from TBCU to be the hardest to play. I actually think you are the first person to upload a fingerstyle song, well besides that epic pro guitarshop one.

Posted 1 month ago #

Broedy

serious fan
Joined: Apr '10
Posts: 78

offline

User has not uploaded an avatar

Agreed, I thought it was good. And I also agree, I find a lot of TBCU stuff to be pretty tough.

Question for all the finger picking style of players. when picking indvidual notes, do you always upstroke with your fingers? do you ever downstroke using your fingernail? I've been messing with different techniques and it never sounds quite right if I down stroke with my nail. may just be me.

Posted 1 month ago #

Danleary

drunken admirer
Joined: Sep '09
Posts: 394

offline

Danleary

I do mostly upstrokes. Downstroke on chords sometimes, depending on what sound I want.

I really wish there were more in depth tutorials on finger style, and pick hand technique in general. You can find a billion things on fret hand technique, but when it comes to picking hand it always seems so much more obscure. It's something I've had to figure out for myself, (which pisses me off, because fret hand stuff is pretty straightforward and easy to figure out on your own. It's the picking hand that's more vague. Everyone seems to do it a bit differently)

Posted 1 month ago #

mdevans

serious fan
Joined: Jun '10
Posts: 59

offline

mdevans

Yeah i got a electric tuner like, its probs just the playing, only just started using open D tbh. TBCU is my favorite album along with Chulahoma. I had a go at countdown too, love this song so much,

Get the Video Plugin

The endings a bit weird lol

Posted 1 month ago #

tbkmagic

drunken admirer
Joined: Feb '10
Posts: 887

offline

tbkmagic

very nice efforts here indeed, i think timing seems a little off but if you played it without TBK in the background it would sound better, seems like your not 100% in time with that like your listening and then playing just delayed after it maybe?

i dunno either way your doing a good job of playing them!

Late at night write something cool in here that people will appreciate.
Posted 1 month ago #

Rollercoaster

massive fan
Joined: Mar '10
Posts: 146

offline

Rollercoaster

I think fingerstyle is especially difficult if one has started out learning guitar by using a guitarpick instead of fingers only. Switching to fingers after being able to play with a pick is kinda tough but it really pays of once you get the hang of it.
The question you've got to ask yourself is if you want to play fingerstyle using only your thumb and indexfinger or more fingers.Many bluesplayers, like for instance Lightnin Hopkins, Junior Kimborough and Dan as well only use there indexfinger for picking the strings.(atleast Dan did on the first two albums) I've got a dvd of Ernie Hawkins teaching Lightnin Hopkins style.There must be parts of it on youtube, I think.Really helpfull!

Posted 1 month ago #

Danleary

drunken admirer
Joined: Sep '09
Posts: 394

offline

Danleary

Dan uses his middle finger too. That's the confusing bit, knowing when to use which finger when switching strings during your runs.

Posted 1 month ago #

tbkmagic

drunken admirer
Joined: Feb '10
Posts: 887

offline

tbkmagic

i generally go by using all first 3 fingers as the bottom 3 strings and then switch first finger between D and G strings. that works for me cause its how i play lapslide so i find it works like that.

Although percussive blues stuff i tend to play sloppy just with my index finger, I like the lazy rough sound of stuffing up!

Posted 1 month ago #

Danleary

drunken admirer
Joined: Sep '09
Posts: 394

offline

Danleary

I usually do thumb on the bass note of whatever I'm playing over, and other fingers chronologically follow suit.

what confuses me is a run like this, where the string that your thumb is on changes

--5--2-----2---------------------------------------------------------------
--------5-----5--2--5--2------2----------------------------------------------
---------------------------4------4---2---4---2-----2-----------------------------
---------------------------------------------------4-----4----2--4--2-----2--------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------4-----4--2-
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5

theres many different ways you can do it. I'm sure there's a "proper" way, but for now I know I'm using bad technique

Posted 1 month ago #

tbkmagic

drunken admirer
Joined: Feb '10
Posts: 887

offline

tbkmagic

puh technique just play! na i'm sure theres heaps of ways of doing things! i find i tend to do what i like, know, and feels comfortable to me. But i intend to be the singer/songwriter type so i don't need the most brilliant guitar playing possible just the rhythm is all i need! Plus maybe some sweet skills! haha

Posted 1 month ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply »

You must log in to post.