The Black Keys Fan Lounge Forum » Music

jillyrose23

massive fan
Joined: Sep '10
Posts: 157

offline

jillyrose23

Big Come Up in Turquoise

For all you collectors

It claims to be limited to 300, but as we've seen with the RSD releases, who knows if that really means just 300.

What are everyone's thoughts on the sound quality of colored vinyl? I've heard it's worse than normal but I try to only buy a record once so I don't have any to compare.

Posted 1 year ago #

Mirby 2.0

tour bus driver
Joined: Apr '10
Posts: 3,640

offline

MirbyGnits

I don't notice any difference in sound quality between colored and black vinyl.

I recently stopped buying new vinyl. I have a dedicated single disc drawer load cd player in my home hi-fi rig and that is feeding a NAD Integrated Amplifier, which is going out to two 3-way tower speakers and a powered sub. It's not high end gear, just entry level stuff, but for new/modern music, the CD gets me better audio than my Audio Technica ATPL120 turntable does. I spent money on an aftermarket cart/stylus, and spent money on an external preamp. It sounds nice and charming for my CCR records and Rolling Stones and Neil Young, etc etc etc. Stuff that was made back when vinyl was the intended/popular format. But for new music... I just don't bother. 99% of the time the CD sounds just as good, costs less, requires less cleaning/maintenence, takes up less space, weighs less...

I think if you have the money for a really REALLY nice vinyl rig, it can be worth it.
And don't get me wrong, vinyl is really cool and fun to collect. I love listening to an album and looking at the artwork all big and stuff. But for most of us, who don't have $5,000+ to spend on the proper rig, I think the CD is the smarter route.

I still have my TBCU, Thickfreakness, Rubber Factory, Chulahoma, Magic Potion vinyl. but I sold my A&R and Brothers vinyl and didn't bother buying El Camino vinyl. I even sold my Black Angels vinyl (all 3) and my Tame Impala vinyl and most of my new vinyl. I have the cd versions of them all and those sound fantastic. For me, new vinyl is more of a collector thing and I don't feel like spending the money on it. The cd sounds just as good, and can be converted to mp3, and will last longer, and costs less.

Beck's Sea Change is one big exception though. That vinyl sounds so damn incredible. It beats the CD. The vinyl sounds more airy and lively and full and deep. But in most cases, I've found the vinyl is just more of a pain in the ass if I'm completely honest with my hipster self.

Sorry, didn't mean to hijack the thread. Got carried away.

"When the power of Love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace." -Jimi Hendrix
Posted 1 year ago #

Rollercoaster

drunken admirer
Joined: Mar '10
Posts: 446

offline

Rollercoaster

I only have TBCU on vinyl. When I play it on 33rpm it plays to slow and when I play it on 45 rpm it plays to fast. Theres no adjusting speedknob on my player. Kinda sucks

Posted 1 year ago #

Mr.ssippi

roadie
Joined: Feb '11
Posts: 1,216

offline

Mr.ssippi

@jillyrose.. I personally have had no issues with the colored vinyl that I own. I think they sound great, just as all the regular black vinyl I have. Only difference is how much more awesome they look!.. As far as that whole limited to 300 thing goes. I think Alive have beat the shit out of that dead horse so much, that its becoming comical. If I remember correctly, this is the 14th or 15th pressing of TBCU... Kiiiinda defeats the purpose of "limited"..

@Rollercoaster.. Do all of your records play to slow, or just TBCU?

Attn Crackheads: Spring is here. Time to pawn your heater!
Posted 1 year ago #

hudsonsaul

massive fan
Joined: Jul '11
Posts: 123

offline

User has not uploaded an avatar

Alive have some great bands but its lol how many 'limited edition' presses of albums they create. Every week there is some other limited addition something or other.

I'm sorta with Mirby with his thoughts on vinyl, I really dig vinyl and collect and listen via it when I can, but don't have the setup to fully appreciate it. I'll buy vinyl with modern music if it comes with a digital download, otherwise the CD will tempt me more, or i'll be resorted to illegally d/l the digital version, and purchase the vinyl. Seems nuts to buy vinyl and not get a d/l version bundled in. Most of my music listening these days is via headphones on the move and at work, and also often plugging in mp3 player into sound systems as its just easier.

I do fucking love it when I get to just sit in the room i've got setup, no interruptions, and spam some vinyl though.

On topic: No idea, I would have thought they'd be the same or a very tiny difference that only a mean ass expensive setup would be able to highlight.

Posted 1 year ago #

Rollercoaster

drunken admirer
Joined: Mar '10
Posts: 446

offline

Rollercoaster

@Mr.ssippi only TBCU plays to slow. Weird huh.

Posted 1 year ago #

jillyrose23

massive fan
Joined: Sep '10
Posts: 157

offline

jillyrose23

I totally get the complaints about vinyl - I try to limit my new vinyl purchases to records that I absolutely love. There's just something about having the music that means the most to me displayed in my living room and being able to just sit on the floor and read the liner notes while I take the time to just sit and listen to an album. I kind of lose that with MP3s and CDs.

The only colored vinyl I have from Alive is "Big Red and Barbacoa" on red vinyl. (which they now have in yellow too, lol) Overall it sounds good, but every once in a while I think it skips, which I've never had happen with other records.

I went ahead and ordered the turquoise, so I'll report back when it comes in.

Posted 1 year ago #

jillyrose23

massive fan
Joined: Sep '10
Posts: 157

offline

jillyrose23

Not what I was expecting, but I like it! (and it sounds great )

Posted 1 year ago #

jrob31

not diehard enough
Joined: Oct '09
Posts: 10

offline

jrob31

jillyrose23 - 20 minutes ago  » 
Not what I was expecting, but I like it! (and it sounds great )

That looks pretty cool.

That also looks like the record player I own.

Posted 1 year ago #

Mr.ssippi

roadie
Joined: Feb '11
Posts: 1,216

offline

Mr.ssippi

@jilly.. Niiiiice! Thats a great lookin' vinyl yall got there. I had no idea they were turquoise-marble?!

Posted 1 year ago #

DeepNDirtyBlues

roadie
Joined: Jan '11
Posts: 1,259

offline

capricorn2972

Love the look of this. Might just have to have it.

I want love to walk right up and bite me, grab a hold of me and fight me, leave me dying on the ground.And I want love to split my mouth wide open and cover up my ears, and never let me hear a sound. ~ Jack White, Love Interruption
Posted 1 year ago #

Peter Blomkvist

drunken admirer
Joined: Sep '09
Posts: 331

offline

fruckin

I believe that they are all quite limited. 300-1000 I think.

But I do think Alive should stop now. I'm up to 18 different copies of TBCU on vinyl. And I think thats quite enough.

I guess they are a bit sad to be loosing this band after only one record. I know I would

"Practice what you preach"
Posted 1 year ago #

jillyrose23

massive fan
Joined: Sep '10
Posts: 157

offline

jillyrose23

I didn't know it was going to be marbled either! Quite the pleasant surprise!

Posted 1 year ago #

Peter Blomkvist

drunken admirer
Joined: Sep '09
Posts: 331

offline

fruckin

And they are selling 180gram vinyl right now?

http://www.alive-totalenergy.com/x/?page_id=392

And the sticker lookes nothing like the one on my record.

http://www.theblackkeys.se/collection_tbcu_vinyl_180_alive.php

Anyone knows something about this?

Posted 1 year ago #

misa

drunken admirer
Joined: Apr '11
Posts: 201

offline

misa

I picked up a 180g TBCU from my local record store a few weeks ago to complement the clear/reversed copy I had (a second issue of the clear vinyl which is an upteenth issue of the original...).

It had a small circular sticker on the top as opposed to the large square sticker on the bottom. Not to say they wouldn't issue yet another version.

I wonder if TBK approve of all the reissues/limited editions or if Alive is just free to try and milk as much out of that record as it can. I'm happy they're readily available for everyone to snag a copy, but its getting ridiculous. I would be happy with a nice 180g standard version of the album they keep producing indefinitely. I guess as long as you're buying, they're selling.

Limited Editon or Marketing Ploy
The Art of Music Merchandising

Posted 1 year ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply »

You must log in to post.